Skip to main content
Call or Text Anytime: 817.277.6166|Office by Appointment  ·  Weekdays 8:30am – 5pm
Back to Insurance Insights
Workers' CompSmall BusinessContractors & Trades

Workers'' Comp in Texas: What Small Business Owners Actually Need to Know

November 18, 20266 min readBy McKnight Insurance Services

Texas is the only state that doesn''t require most private employers to carry workers'' compensation — but opting out carries serious risks. Here''s what small business owners need to understand before making that decision.

Workers' Comp in Texas: What Small Business Owners Actually Need to Know

Texas is the only state in the country that doesn't require most private employers to carry workers' compensation insurance. That fact leads a lot of small business owners to assume they don't need it — or to opt out without fully understanding what they're taking on.

The reality is more complicated. Opting out of workers' comp in Texas doesn't mean you're off the hook if an employee gets hurt. It means you're exposed to a different — and potentially much larger — liability. At McKnight Insurance Services in Mansfield, we work with small business owners and contractors throughout the Dallas-Fort Worth area. Here's what you actually need to know before making this decision.


How Texas Workers' Comp Works Differently

In most states, workers' compensation is mandatory. Employers pay into the system, injured employees receive defined benefits, and the workers' comp system is the exclusive remedy — employees generally can't sue their employer in civil court for a workplace injury.

Texas opted out of mandatory participation. Private employers (with some exceptions) can choose whether to participate in the workers' comp system or not.

If you participate (subscriber): Injured employees receive workers' comp benefits — medical care, income replacement, death benefits. The workers' comp system is the exclusive remedy; employees generally can't sue you in civil court. Your liability is defined and limited.

If you opt out (non-subscriber): Injured employees can sue you directly in civil court. There's no cap on damages — they can recover for pain and suffering, lost future earnings, and other damages beyond medical bills and lost wages. You also lose the ability to use three common-law defenses: contributory negligence, assumption of risk, and the fellow-servant rule.

That last point matters. In a civil lawsuit brought by an injured employee, a non-subscriber cannot argue that the employee was partly at fault, that the employee knew the job was dangerous, or that a coworker caused the injury. The deck is stacked against you.


Who Is Required to Carry Workers' Comp in Texas

Even though Texas doesn't require workers' comp for most private employers, there are exceptions:

  • Government contractors — businesses that contract with state or local government entities are typically required to carry workers' comp for employees working on those contracts
  • Motor carriers — certain transportation businesses regulated by the Texas Department of Transportation
  • Some regulated industries — check your industry's specific requirements
Beyond legal requirements, many general contractors and commercial clients require subcontractors to carry workers' comp as a condition of the contract. If you work as a sub on commercial projects, you may effectively be required to carry it regardless of state law.


The Real Cost of Going Without

Here's the math that matters. A workers' comp claim for a broken arm might cost $15,000–$30,000 in medical bills and lost wages. Under workers' comp, that's a defined, covered claim.

Without workers' comp, that same injury becomes a civil lawsuit. Add pain and suffering, lost future earnings if there's permanent impairment, and attorney fees — and a claim that would have cost $25,000 under workers' comp can become a $150,000–$500,000 judgment. For a small business, that's a business-ending number.

The annual premium for workers' comp on a small crew is almost always a fraction of what a single uninsured claim would cost.


Understanding Your Premium: Classifications and the E-Mod

Workers' comp premium is calculated based on three factors:

Payroll — the more payroll you have, the higher the base premium. Premium is expressed as a rate per $100 of payroll.

Classification codes — every job type has a classification code with an associated rate. Roofing (one of the highest-risk classifications) carries a much higher rate than clerical work. If your employees do multiple types of work, make sure they're classified correctly — misclassification in either direction creates problems at audit.

Experience modification factor (e-mod) — your claims history compared to other businesses in your industry. A clean history produces an e-mod below 1.0, which reduces your premium. A history of claims produces an e-mod above 1.0, which increases it. Your e-mod is calculated over a three-year rolling window.

The Audit

Workers' comp policies are written on estimated payroll and audited at the end of the policy year based on actual payroll. If your payroll was higher than estimated, you'll owe additional premium. If it was lower, you'll receive a refund or credit.

Subcontractors are a common audit surprise. If a sub you hired doesn't carry their own workers' comp, their payroll may be included in your audit — and you'll pay the rate for their job classification. Always collect certificates of insurance from every sub before work begins.


Workers' Comp for Contractors in the DFW Area

For contractors — concrete crews, landscapers, tree service companies, pool builders, roofers, HVAC techs, plumbers, electricians — workers' comp is especially important. The injury exposure is real and present on every job. Cuts, falls, equipment injuries, heat illness, chemical exposure — these aren't hypothetical risks.

If you're working on commercial projects or as a sub for a GC, you almost certainly need workers' comp to get on the job. And if you have employees doing physical work, the cost of going without is a risk most small business owners shouldn't take.


Serving Small Businesses and Contractors Across Mansfield, DFW, and All of Texas

McKnight Insurance Services is based in Mansfield, Texas, and we work with small business owners and contractors throughout the Dallas-Fort Worth area — Tarrant County, Johnson County, Ellis County, and beyond. We're an independent agency, which means we shop your workers' comp coverage across multiple carriers to find the program that fits your crew, your classifications, and your budget.

Ready to get your workers' comp sorted out?

Call or text 817.277.6166, or start your application online. We'll walk through your payroll, your job classifications, and your current coverage to make sure you're protected — and not paying more than you should.

McKnight Insurance Services

We are an independent insurance agency serving the Dallas-Fort Worth area and beyond.

Contact Us

817.277.6166

Call or Text Anytime

Office by Appointment

Weekdays 8:30am – 5pm

Mansfield, TX

Follow Us

Copyright 2025 | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy

This material is for informational purposes only. All statements herein are subject to the provisions, exclusions and conditions of the applicable policy, state and federal laws.